Thursday, 10 March 2016

Easy chair



[This picture is from the website http://montazne-hise-on.net/nenavadni-pocivalniki.html]

Another day, another Freedom of Information request. 

A pretty repugnant feature of recent Southern Health practice has been the threatening behaviour of the new Chairman of the Southern Health Board, Mike Petter, towards members of the public in board meetings. How he behaves as Chairman of the Governors (those are the governors that are independent and can hold the Board to account, including sacking Board members like their, er, Chairman - ooh stop it, my accountability sides are hurting) doesn't bear thinking about. 

Mike Petter's association with Southern Health is long (even going back to its previous incarnation before 2011). Given we're always being told how vastly competitive these senior Board posts are - and let's face it, for this post up to £50,000 a year for a part-time gig must be pretty tasty to a lot of people - I was interested in just how fiercely Mike Petter had to compete to get his job. Such prestige, Vanguard among Vanguards, working with former CEO of the year Katrina Percy, surely it was a comprehensive, searching, Apprentice-style selection process to pick out the Petter plum from the thousands of desperate applicants? So I did a Freedom of Information request to ask a few simple questions, via the excellent WhatDoTheyKnow (see here https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/selection_process_for_current_ch#followup )

From this (and despite the expensive ministrations of executive recruitment wizards Odgers Berndtsen), we learn that a princely total of 7 people formally applied for the post of Chairman.

Of these, 3 were shortlisted by the 'Appointment Committee' on 22 June 2015. There is no more detail about who was on the Appointment Committee, but a previous (and rather sniffy) response to an FoI request put in by Richard West (see here https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/details_of_panel_selecting_chair ) basically says that the Appointment Committee is constituted of Trust governors. 

Of these 3 shortlisted candidates, 1 withdrew, leaving just 2 people.

According to the response to my request, "This was then followed by a Stakeholder Day on 29 June 2015, which was made up of Governors, Service Users and Board members". It is not clear what role this played in selection, or how this fed into any final decision, but it seems that the 2 remaining candidates must have been there, as they also 'took part in psychometric testing' on the same day (29 June). A couple of thoughts at this point. First, I would love to know what psychometric tests were done and what the criteria were for evaluating scores on them. Second, a week between shortlisting and final selection is an incredibly short period of time, particularly if they were hoping to attract the sort of highly competent people with busy diaries suitable for a big Trust like Southern Health.

 'Final panel interviews' then took place the next day, on 30 June 2015, with the Appointment Committee and also a shadowy 'External Assessor'. There is no more information about who this External Assessor was, and this information seems to directly contradict what Richard West was told in the response to his FoI request. 

Overall, this seems a remarkably light process for selecting a Chair of a large, vanguardy NHS Trust. Application form, chat to a few people, a few psychometric tests and an interview, all with people presumably well-known to the successful candidate. 

When I was a governor of my kids' primary school we had to appoint a new headteacher. The appointment panel was 3 governors (including me) and two external assessors with considerable and complementary experience and expertise. After shortlisting, the selection tasks included a data task (looking at school attainment data and interpreting it), conducting a short assembly, conducting a lesson, observing and providing feedback on a teacher's lesson, answering questions from pupils on the school council, and a structured interview. The tasks were designed to cover the range of things that a good head teacher would be expected to do, and to get feedback from kids and teachers as well as governors and external assessors. And they really made a difference to who we selected.

It's almost as if the process to select a Chairman of Southern Health Trust wasn't designed to attract as many high-powered, capable people as possible, and then really put them through their paces to see which one actually had what it takes to be a competent, ethical Chair of an NHS Trust. Surely not...










16 comments:

  1. Take Rolex. While replica watches anybody now recognizes the name, aback in replica watches uk the 1950s and 1960s the cast was accepted about alone by the pilots and able defined who rolex replica in fact bare the functions the watches offered.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The Days of Judgement thing is hideous. Second of all I'm guessing you are a liberal weeny, because they think money is the answer to everything.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is really very useful information that I have come across through searching the keyword swiss copy watches

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ik ben een grote fan van de replica horloges nederland Tag Heuer replica horloges. Het is onmogelijk om niet te willen hun ontwerpen en wat dit merk voor staat. Het heeft een lange geschiedenis en sinds het begin, is dit merk in verband gebracht met een superieure tijdmeting. Edouard Heuer gesticht in 1860. Dit bedrijf en haar producten de replica horloges tag heuer normen voor precisie in uurwerken. Zij ontwikkelden innovatieve stopwatches, chronografen, waterbestendig horloges en nog veel meer. Tag Heuer uitvinder van de eerste chronograaf in 1882. Zoals u kunt zien, zijn er vele redenen dat dit merk maakte een van de beste en meest gewilde replica horloges rolex. Elke horlogeliefhebber dromen over het bezitten van een dag.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Es una pieza clásica de Rolex replicas relojes, pero todavía muy actualizada. Fácil de personalizar, pero todavía creo que necesita un enfoque más informal y un poco de estilo. Simplemente no se sentiría bien usar esta falsa Rolex con sus zapatillas de deporte promedio si sabes lo que quiero decir. Caso es completamente pulido caja de acero inoxidable y se ve bien con la corona de oro amarillo chapado. Creo que son los números que hacen que este reloj parezca más fresco y nuevo que cualquier otra cosa porque replicas rolex todos los otros elementos son simplemente clásicos. Brazalete presidencial tiene el logotipo de Rolex en el cierre y grabados en el interior.

    La etiqueta verde replicas breitling del holograma y el número de serie están presentes en el caso trasero pero este detalle cuenta tan poco estos días. El mecanismo de corte se enciende al ajustar la hora en este movimiento automático japonés. Segundos mano tiene un buen barrido, aunque cuando hago zoom en la cámara parece que las garrapatas más de lo que barridos. Vamos a dar esta réplica Rolex Datejust a un muy buen amigo de replicas omega mi papá para su cumpleaños el próximo mes y sé que él va a amar y tal vez incluso él fuera de viaje en primer lugar porque sé que tiene algunos relojes originales uno de Siendo una Rolex. Echa un vistazo al video y házmelo saber cómo te gusta este reloj Rolex Datejust falso.

    ReplyDelete
  6. cheap Soccer Jerseys is the best soccer jerseys wholesale supplier.cheap xavi hernandez Jerseys Buy the cheap soccer jerseys, soccer shirts, soccer kits, training kits with wholesale price.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Rolex watches are crafted from the finest raw materials and assembled with scrupulous attention to detail. cheap replica watchesEvery component is designed, replica rolex watchesdeveloped and produced in-house to the most exacting standards.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Louis Vuitton himself was born the son of a miller in 1821 in Anchay, a hamlet in the Jura Mountains, not far from the Swiss border. Replica bagsThe region was a poor one - serfdom had only been abolished less than 40 years previously, so Louis left to seek his fortune when he was a teenager, arriving in the French capital aged 16. This was the Paris of Victor Hugo's Les Misérables, with nearly one million inhabitants. As the composer Chopin said in a letter to a friend at the time, "Here you find the greatest luxury and the greatest filth, the greatest virtue and the greatest vice."replica Louis Vuiton bags

    ReplyDelete
  9. What makes Giuseppe Zanotti pumps, Giuseppe Zanotti sandals, replica giuseppe zanotti uk and Giuseppe Zanotti boots so unique is cheap man giuseppe zanotti espadrilles their consummate synthesis of design awareness and quality: "design awareness keeps you up to speed with the major trends that, season after season, dominate the worlds of ready-to-wear and haute couture; and it's also important for building up a repertory of ideas and images taken from music videos, from art, the cinema, from design, in short from everything which reflects changing fashions," explained Zanotti. "Technique and taste work in a reciprocal relationship, allowing all these ideas to come together."

    ReplyDelete
  10. Cartier is the renowned French jeweller and watchmaker with swiss replica watches a history of pioneering design and a drive for excellence. replica rolex watches The first references to Cartier wristwatches date back to 1888. Late in the 19th century it was pocket and chatelaine watches that were most popular, but Louis Cartier saw a future in timepieces that could be worn on the wrist.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Use Alexander McQueen shoes to create a look from the feet.Cheap ALEXANDER MCQUEEN Shoes Wacky women's sneakers use jewellery replica mens ALEXANDER MCQUEEN embellishments and iconic skull motifs to instantly elevate any casual outfit to luxury, while glossy leather boots

    ReplyDelete
  12. nike air max scarpe Acquista scarpe Nike da uomo su replichenk.com. repliche air huarache Ottieni le ultime sneaker Nike da uomo in una gamma di colori e dimensioni. trovi un prezzo più basso su uomini e donne Nike.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Montblanc MeisterstückClassique black ballpoint pen with gold accessories replica mont blanc uk is one of the most famous Montblanc fountain pens replica mont blanc donation pens and is considered one of the writing instruments. The design icon has a white snow cap insignia and has its own personal serial number, which means that the pen you own will be unique. Montblanc ballpoint pens are a must-have Montblanc ballpoint pens, popular with gift buyers, corporate customers and serious pen collectors. The smoothness of the ballpoint pen mechanism makes writing luxurious and enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete
  14. www.2020jerseyshop.com provides you high quality and cheap Soccer Jerseys, wholesale soccer jerseys.cheap yerry mina Jerseys You can buy cheap club soccer jerseys and national team soccer .

    ReplyDelete
  15. Replica luxury handbags and watches, free shipping worldwide,the highest quality and lowest price,GUCCI LV DIOR CHANEL PRADA please contact Whats App+8618100140127 website:kelly online shop

    https://www.zhongximaoyi.com

    ReplyDelete